Odd one out is one of the most common non-verbal reasoning question types in 11+ papers, whether the test is GL Assessment style, CEM-influenced, or set by an independent school. Children are shown four or five figures and asked to find the one that does not belong. It sounds simple, but most marks are lost because children compare figures in pairs rather than looking for a rule that covers the whole set.
This guide sets out a clear method, works through two full examples step by step, and flags the mistakes that examiners see most often.
What these questions are actually testing
Odd one out questions are testing whether a child can hold several features in mind at once — shape, number, size, shading, position, rotation, symmetry — and work out which single feature (or combination of two features) is the one that all but one figure share. It is a test of systematic thinking, not of spotting the most visually different shape, which is a trap many children fall into.
The five features that come up again and again are:
- Number of sides or number of shapes
- Number of small elements inside a shape (dots, lines, ticks)
- Shading or colour (black, white, striped, dotted)
- Symmetry (number of lines of symmetry, or whether the figure is symmetrical at all)
- Size or rotation of the figure
Most questions use one rule. Harder questions, especially in independent school papers, combine two rules at once, so a figure might fit the first rule but break the second.
A step-by-step method
- Look at all five figures together before focusing on any one. Do not start by comparing figure A with figure B; that leads to spotting a difference that turns out to be irrelevant.
- Count something in every figure — sides, dots, lines, angles — and write the numbers down if your child is practising on paper. A quick tally takes seconds and prevents miscounting under pressure.
- Look for shading and symmetry separately from counting. These are often the rule when counting does not reveal one.
- Test a rule against all five figures. If it holds for four and fails for one, that is the answer. If it fails for two or more, the rule is wrong and you need a different one.
- Check for a second rule. In trickier questions, one figure can satisfy the main rule but break a smaller, second rule (for example, right shading but wrong orientation).
Worked example 1: counting rule
Five figures, A to E, each a polygon with a number of dots inside it.
| Figure | Shape | Number of sides | Dots inside |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Square | 4 | 2 |
| B | Pentagon | 5 | 3 |
| C | Hexagon | 6 | 4 |
| D | Heptagon | 7 | 5 |
| E | Octagon | 8 | 5 |
Step 1: count the sides of each shape: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. No single number repeats, so the rule is not about matching shapes.
Step 2: count the dots: 2, 3, 4, 5, 5. Two figures share 5 dots, which is worth noticing.
Step 3: test a rule linking sides to dots. For A, 4 sides and 2 dots: 4 minus 2 is 2, which matches. For B, 5 minus 2 is 3, which matches. For C, 6 minus 2 is 4, which matches. For D, 7 minus 2 is 5, which matches.
Step 4: check E against the same rule. E has 8 sides, so 8 minus 2 is 6. But E only has 5 dots. The rule breaks for E.
Answer: E is the odd one out, because every other figure follows “dots equal sides minus two” and E does not.
Worked example 2: symmetry rule
Five figures, A to E, each a regular or irregular polygon.
| Figure | Shape | Number of sides | Lines of symmetry |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Equilateral triangle | 3 | 3 |
| B | Square | 4 | 4 |
| C | Regular pentagon | 5 | 5 |
| D | Regular hexagon | 6 | 6 |
| E | Rectangle (not square) | 4 | 2 |
Step 1: count the sides: 3, 4, 5, 6, 4. B and E both have 4 sides, so side count alone will not separate them.
Step 2: count the lines of symmetry: 3, 4, 5, 6, 2. For A, B, C and D, the number of lines of symmetry exactly equals the number of sides — this is always true for a regular polygon.
Step 3: check E. It has 4 sides but only 2 lines of symmetry, because a rectangle that is not a square is not a regular polygon.
Answer: E is the odd one out. Note that E looked similar to B at first glance (both four-sided), which is exactly the kind of trap these questions set.
Common mistakes
- Comparing pairs instead of the whole set. A child spots that figure A and figure C look different and picks one of them, without checking whether B, D and E share a rule that A or C actually follows.
- Picking the most visually unusual figure. The figure that looks oddest is sometimes a deliberate decoy. The correct answer is defined by breaking a rule, not by looking strange.
- Stopping after finding one matching feature. If a rule fits four figures on, say, shading, but the fifth figure also fits that rule and breaks a different one (size, or number of sides), the child needs to look further.
- Miscounting under time pressure. Dots, sides and small lines are easy to lose count of in a six or seven second window. Training a habit of counting once, carefully, is more reliable than counting twice quickly.
- Giving up on hard questions rather than guessing with logic. If no single rule fits, trying two features at once (shading and shape, or size and rotation) often reveals it.
If you have a marked paper in front of you, look specifically at how odd one out questions were lost: was it a miscount, a rule spotted too early, or a genuinely tricky two-rule question? Uploading a past paper to Your 11+ Lab shows this pattern question by question, rather than as a single non-verbal reasoning score, which makes it much easier to target practice where it is actually needed.
How to practise this at home
Short, frequent practice works better than long sessions for this question type. Five to ten odd one out questions, three times a week, with your child explaining the rule out loud each time, builds the habit faster than one long weekly session. Ask “what is the rule?” rather than “which one is the odd one out?” — naming the rule is the skill that transfers to new, unfamiliar questions on the day.
It also helps to see this question type in the context of non-verbal reasoning as a whole, alongside codes and series questions, since many papers mix all three in the same section.
Related guides
- 11+ non-verbal reasoning: all question types explained
- NVR codes explained
- NVR series questions
- How to use 11+ past papers properly
Try one
Four of the five figures below share a rule. Which one does not belong?
Figure A: a square (4 sides) with 2 dots inside.
Figure B: a pentagon (5 sides) with 3 dots inside.
Figure C: a hexagon (6 sides) with 4 dots inside.
Figure D: a heptagon (7 sides) with 5 dots inside.
Figure E: an octagon (8 sides) with 5 dots inside.
- Figure A
- Figure B
- Figure C
- Figure D
- Figure E
Show the answer
Figure E
Count the sides and dots in each figure. A has 4 sides and 2 dots (4 minus 2 equals 2). B has 5 sides and 3 dots (5 minus 2 equals 3). C has 6 sides and 4 dots (6 minus 2 equals 4). D has 7 sides and 5 dots (7 minus 2 equals 5). The rule is dots equal sides minus two. E has 8 sides, so it should have 6 dots, but it only has 5, so E breaks the rule and is the odd one out.
Quick answers
At what age do children meet odd one out questions?
They appear from Year 4 onwards in non-verbal reasoning practice and are common in both GL Assessment style papers and independent school entrance tests sat in Year 6. Some schools, including those using the ISEB Common Pre-Test, include them within a broader non-verbal reasoning section.
Do odd one out questions always have just one rule?
No. Easier questions usually have one rule, such as number of sides or shading. Harder questions, especially later in a paper, often combine two rules, where a figure can satisfy one but break the other.
How can I tell if my child is guessing rather than reasoning?
Ask them to say the rule out loud after they answer. If they can describe exactly what the other four figures share and why the odd one breaks it, they are reasoning properly. If they can only say it looked different, they are guessing.
Is odd one out the same across all 11+ test providers?
The underlying skill is the same, but presentation varies by test and region, so it is worth checking how non-verbal reasoning is weighted in your specific exam, for example the Kent Test or the Medway Test, as formats differ slightly between providers.
Your 11+ Lab
Upload your child's paper. Get it marked, question by question.
Full and partial marks, what went right and wrong, and a mini lesson for every mistake, then practice on exactly those topics. For Year 4, 5 and 6.
See plansFree download
The 20 most-missed 11+ questions
The question types children lose the most marks on, in maths, verbal reasoning and English. Each one shows the answer, the usual mistake and the fast method. A free 5-page PDF, sent to your inbox.
You'll also get a few short 11+ tips over the next two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.