Comprehension papers reward children who answer fully, not children who merely understand the text. A child can read a passage perfectly well and still lose two or three marks on a page simply because their answers are too short, too vague, or missing a piece the mark scheme is looking for. The good news is that answering in full is a learnable skill, with a clear method behind it.
What examiners mean by "in full"
When a mark scheme says a question is worth two or three marks, it usually means there are two or three separate, identifiable things the examiner wants to see. These might be: a correct point, a piece of evidence from the text that supports it, and an explanation of why that evidence matters. Many children write a correct but single-point answer to a three-mark question, and are then confused when they only get one mark back.
Answering in full does not mean writing a long essay. It means matching the depth of the answer to the marks available, writing in full sentences rather than single words or phrases, and always showing your reasoning rather than leaving the examiner to guess it.
The method: point, evidence, explain
A reliable structure for most comprehension answers worth two marks or more is:
- Point — answer the question directly in a full sentence.
- Evidence — refer to or quote the part of the text that supports the point.
- Explain — say what that evidence shows or why it matters, especially for inference questions.
For a one-mark question, usually just the point is needed, stated clearly. For two marks, point and evidence, or point and explanation. For three marks or more, all three elements, sometimes with two separate points if the question asks for more than one reason or example.
Worked example 1: a two-mark question
Passage extract: "Tom pressed himself flat against the cold stone wall, hardly daring to breathe. The footsteps grew louder, then stopped just outside the gate. He counted to ten, twenty, thirty, before he finally let out the breath he had been holding."
Question: Why did Tom count to ten, twenty, thirty? (2 marks)
- Read the question carefully. It is asking for a reason behind an action, not just what happened.
- Find the evidence. The surrounding sentences show Tom pressed against a wall, was hardly breathing, and the footsteps had stopped nearby. This tells us he was hiding and afraid of being found.
- Build the point. He was counting to force himself to wait, so that he could be sure the danger had passed before moving.
- Write the full answer. "Tom counted to ten, twenty, thirty because he was trying to make himself wait until he was sure the footsteps outside the gate had gone, since he was too frightened to move until he felt safe."
This answer earns two marks: one for identifying that he was waiting until it was safe, and one for linking this to his fear, supported by the detail of him holding his breath. A child who writes only "because he was scared" would earn one mark, because the answer does not explain what he was scared of or why counting helped.
Worked example 2: a three-mark question
Passage extract: "Maya shuffled her feet in the queue, eyes fixed on the floor. When the stallholder finally called her name, she stepped forward reluctantly, as though each step cost her something."
Question: What does the word "reluctantly" tell us about how Maya was feeling? (3 marks)
- Define the word in context. Reluctantly means unwillingly, or showing hesitation.
- Name the feeling. Maya appears nervous, uneasy, or dreading what was about to happen.
- Find supporting evidence. She shuffled her feet, kept her eyes on the floor, and each step seemed to cost her something, all before she moved.
- Write the full answer. "The word 'reluctantly' tells us that Maya did not want to step forward and felt nervous or unwilling, which is shown by her shuffling her feet, keeping her eyes on the floor, and each step seeming to 'cost her something'."
This earns three marks: one for the correct meaning of the word, one for naming the feeling, and one for specific supporting evidence from the text. A child who writes "she felt reluctant" without explaining what that feeling was or why has only restated the question and would score zero or one mark at most.
Questions like this one often shade into inference, where the answer is not stated directly in the text but has to be worked out from clues. For more on that particular skill, see 11+ comprehension inference questions.
Common mistakes that lose marks
- Writing one word or a short phrase where the mark scheme expects a full sentence with reasoning.
- Quoting without explaining. A quotation on its own rarely earns full marks; the child needs to say what it shows.
- Answering only part of a multi-part question. If a question asks "why" and "how do you know", both parts need an answer.
- Copying when the question asks for "your own words". Lifting a phrase straight from the passage when paraphrasing was required usually loses marks, even if the meaning is correct.
- Ignoring the number of marks as a guide. A one-line answer to a four-mark question is almost always too short, however neat the writing.
- Running out of time to finish the comprehension section, leaving later, often higher-value, questions blank.
How marks guide the amount of detail needed
| Marks available | What the answer usually needs |
|---|---|
| 1 mark | A single clear point, in a full short sentence |
| 2 marks | A point plus evidence, or a point plus a brief explanation |
| 3 marks | A point, evidence from the text, and an explanation of what it shows |
| 4 or more marks | Two or more separate points, each with its own evidence |
Seeing exactly which of these elements a child is missing is far easier with a marked paper in front of you, because the pattern usually repeats across the whole script. Uploading a past paper to Your 11+ Lab shows question by question whether marks are being lost on evidence, on explanation, or simply on brevity, with a short lesson attached to each type of slip.
Putting it into practice
The best way to build this skill is through real past papers rather than isolated worksheets, since exam boards vary slightly in how they phrase questions and allocate marks. For general guidance on using past papers well, see how to use 11+ past papers properly, and for understanding how marking actually works, including partial marks, see how to mark an 11+ paper at home. If you are still finding your way around the 11+ process more broadly, what is the 11+? is a good starting point.
Try one
Read the extract, then answer the question below.
"At the top of the hill, Priya stopped running and looked back at the town below, its rooftops glowing orange in the last of the evening light. She had never seen it look so small, so far away, and for the first time she didn't feel afraid of leaving it behind."
Explain, using evidence from the passage, why Priya no longer feels afraid of leaving the town behind. (3 marks)
Show the answer
Priya no longer feels afraid because seeing the town looking small and far away, from a distance, makes it seem less important or less powerful over her, shown by the phrase "she had never seen it look so small, so far away", which changes how she sees her future away from it.
First, identify the point: her feelings change because of how the town looks from the hill. Second, find the evidence: the phrase "so small, so far away" shows the town now looks less significant than before. Third, explain the link: if the town looks small and distant, it feels less powerful or frightening, which is why she stops being afraid of leaving it. A full three-mark answer needs all three parts: the point, the quoted or referenced evidence, and the explanation connecting them.
Quick answers
How long should a comprehension answer be for the 11+?
As a rough guide, allow one clear point per mark available, written in a full sentence rather than a single word. A two-mark question usually needs a point plus evidence, while a four-mark question needs two separate points, each supported.
Should my child copy words straight from the passage?
Only when the question explicitly asks for a quotation. If it asks for an answer "in your own words", copying a phrase directly usually loses marks, even when the meaning is correct, so children need to practise paraphrasing.
Why does my child understand the passage but still lose marks?
This is extremely common and usually means answers are too short or missing the explanation step, not that the child has misunderstood the text. Checking a marked paper question by question is the quickest way to see which part of the answer is being left out.
Your 11+ Lab
Upload your child's paper. Get it marked, question by question.
Full and partial marks, what went right and wrong, and a mini lesson for every mistake, then practice on exactly those topics. For Year 4, 5 and 6.
See plansFree download
The 20 most-missed 11+ questions
The question types children lose the most marks on, in maths, verbal reasoning and English. Each one shows the answer, the usual mistake and the fast method. A free 5-page PDF, sent to your inbox.
You'll also get a few short 11+ tips over the next two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.