Home›Guides›Preparation

Grammar school vs independent school: how to choose

The choice often comes down to money, how each school selects pupils, and what suits your child, not simply which option sounds more impressive. Here's what each route actually involves, what it costs, and how to think it through calmly.

Updated 19 October 2026

Many parents start 11+ preparation assuming it's a single path, then discover grammar schools and independent schools work quite differently, test differently, and cost completely different amounts. Understanding both before Year 5 makes the decisions in Year 6 far less stressful.

The basic difference

Grammar schools are state funded, which means no fees, and they select pupils using an academic test, usually sat in Year 6 (September intake the following year). They follow the national curriculum and sit within the normal state admissions system, so you still apply through your local authority alongside your grammar school application.

Independent schools are privately funded through fees. They set their own entrance process, which might be a formal written exam, the ISEB Common Pre-Test, an interview, a report from the current school, or a combination of all of these. For a full explanation of the test formats, see what is the 11+? A plain-English guide for parents and the ISEB Common Pre-Test explained.

How selection works at each

Grammar school selection is usually a single test day, or occasionally two, covering some combination of verbal reasoning, non-verbal reasoning, maths and English, depending on the area. Pass marks and scoring methods vary by region and by school, and some areas rank candidates rather than setting a fixed pass mark.

Independent school selection tends to run over a longer window. Many schools use the ISEB Common Pre-Test in the autumn of Year 6, then follow up with their own English and maths papers, a short interview, and a reference from the child's current primary school. Smaller or more specialist independent schools sometimes run their own exam from the start rather than using the pre-test at all.

What each costs

Grammar school places are free once your child is offered one. The real cost tends to sit in preparation beforehand, whether that's tutoring, workbooks, or the time a parent spends marking practice papers. Many families spend nothing beyond a few workbooks; others spend a year or more on weekly tutoring.

Independent school fees vary enormously by school and region, but as a rough guide, day fees commonly sit somewhere between £15,000 and £22,000 a year, with boarding fees considerably higher. Fees usually rise a little each year, and most schools charge extra for trips, music lessons, lunches or exam board fees on top of the headline figure. Always check the current figure on the school's own website rather than relying on a number you've seen elsewhere, since fees change annually.

FactorGrammar schoolIndependent school
FeesNoneTypically £15,000–£22,000/year (day)
SelectionSingle academic test, set pass mark or rankingPre-test, own papers, interview, school reference
Main cost to parentsPreparation (tutoring, materials)Fees plus preparation
Financial help availableN/AMeans-tested bursaries, academic/music scholarships

Worked example: the real cost over seven years

It helps to see the gap in plain numbers rather than headline fee figures alone. Say an independent school charges £18,000 a year for a day place, from Year 7 to Year 13.

  1. Annual fee: £18,000
  2. Number of years, Year 7 to Year 13: 7
  3. Total cost: £18,000 × 7 = £126,000

Compare that with a grammar school place, which costs £0 in fees over the same seven years, though a family might spend, say, £1,500 on tutoring in Year 5 beforehand. The gap is the £124,500 difference, which is exactly why bursaries matter so much to families considering the independent route.

Bursaries and scholarships: making independent affordable

Scholarships are awards for academic, music, sport or art ability, usually worth a modest discount on fees (often 10–20%), and they're not meant to make a place affordable on their own. Bursaries are the bigger lever: these are means-tested awards based on household income, and at many schools they can cover a significant portion of fees, occasionally up to 100% for families with the lowest income. For a full breakdown of how bursary assessments work and what schools ask for, see 11+ bursaries explained: how families get fees covered.

Worked example: what a bursary actually saves you

Suppose the same school with £18,000 annual fees offers your family a 50% means-tested bursary.

  1. Original annual fee: £18,000
  2. Bursary percentage: 50%
  3. Discount: £18,000 × 0.5 = £9,000
  4. Fee you actually pay: £18,000 − £9,000 = £9,000 a year
  5. Over seven years: £9,000 × 7 = £63,000

That's still a significant sum, but it's roughly half the full-fee total, and it changes the comparison with a grammar school considerably. If you're weighing up an independent school, it's worth applying for a bursary assessment early, since most schools want financial information well before the entrance exam itself, not after an offer is made.

Tip: Ask each independent school directly what proportion of their current pupils receive a bursary, and what the average award is worth. Published fee tables only tell you the maximum anyone pays, not what most families actually pay.

Partially selective schools

Not every school sits neatly in the grammar or independent category. Some state secondary schools are partially selective, meaning they select a set proportion of their intake, often between 10% and 30%, by an ability test, while the rest of the places go on catchment, faith criteria, or general admissions rules. This is more common in some areas than others, and you'll find it alongside fully selective grammar school systems in places like Kent. See the Kent Test explained for how a mixed selective system works in practice.

A handful of independent schools also operate a looser form of selection, admitting most children who apply at the right academic level and reserving a smaller number of more competitive places for scholarships. It's worth asking a school directly how selective their process really is, rather than assuming from reputation alone.

How many families sit both

It's genuinely common for families to prepare their child for both a grammar school test and one or more independent school entrance exams in the same year, particularly in areas where the two systems overlap, such as parts of Kent, Essex, Buckinghamshire and outer London. Doing both gives a family more choice once offers come in during the spring, and it isn't unusual for a child to hold a grammar school place and an independent school offer with a bursary at the same time, then decide between them in March. The trade-off is preparation load: different test formats mean more varied practice, not just more of the same.

How to decide

A few honest questions tend to cut through the noise more than any league table:

Use our school finder to see which grammar and independent schools sit within a reasonable commute of you, and compare their admissions criteria and any published bursary information side by side. If your child has already sat a practice paper for either route, uploading it to Your 11+ Lab shows exactly which question types are costing marks, which is useful whether you end up applying to one system or both.

Try one

An independent school charges £16,500 a year in day fees. A family is awarded a means-tested bursary covering 40% of fees. How much will the family pay per year after the bursary?

  1. £6,600
  2. £9,900
  3. £10,500
  4. £11,900
Show the answer

£9,900

First find the discount: 40% of £16,500 is £16,500 × 0.4 = £6,600. Then subtract this from the full fee: £16,500 − £6,600 = £9,900. That's the amount the family actually pays each year.

Quick answers

Can a child sit both the grammar school 11+ and an independent school entrance exam?

Yes, this is common practice, especially in areas where both systems operate. The tests usually run on different dates with different formats, so it's a matter of preparing for both rather than a clash of timing.

Do independent schools require the ISEB Common Pre-Test?

Many do, particularly for Year 7 entry, but not all. Some schools set their own papers instead, so it's worth checking each school's admissions page rather than assuming the pre-test applies everywhere.

How much do bursaries typically cover?

It varies widely by school and by household income, from a small percentage up to, occasionally, the full fee for the lowest-income families. Schools assess this individually, so the only reliable figure is the one you get from applying directly.

Your 11+ Lab

Upload your child's paper. Get it marked, question by question.

Full and partial marks, what went right and wrong, and a mini lesson for every mistake, then practice on exactly those topics. For Year 4, 5 and 6.

See plans

Free download

The 20 most-missed 11+ questions

The question types children lose the most marks on, in maths, verbal reasoning and English. Each one shows the answer, the usual mistake and the fast method. A free 5-page PDF, sent to your inbox.

You'll also get a few short 11+ tips over the next two weeks. Unsubscribe any time.

More guides